Indirect acute effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on physical and mental health in the UK: a population-based study
Summary
Background
There are concerns that the response to the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK might have worsened physical and mental health, and reduced use of health services. However, the scale of the problem is unquantified, impeding development of effective mitigations. We aimed to ascertain what has happened to general practice contacts for acute physical and mental health outcomes during the pandemic.
Methods
Using de-identified electronic health records from the Clinical Research Practice Datalink (CPRD) Aurum (covering 13% of the UK population), between 2017 and 2020, we calculated weekly primary care contacts for selected acute physical and mental health conditions: anxiety, depression, self-harm (fatal and non-fatal), severe mental illness, eating disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, acute alcohol-related events, asthma exacerbation, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease exacerbation, acute cardiovascular events (cerebrovascular accident, heart failure, myocardial infarction, transient ischaemic attacks, unstable angina, and venous thromboembolism), and diabetic emergency. Primary care contacts included remote and face-to-face consultations, diagnoses from hospital discharge letters, and secondary care referrals, and conditions were identified through primary care records for diagnoses, symptoms, and prescribing. Our overall study population included individuals aged 11 years or older who had at least 1 year of registration with practices contributing to CPRD Aurum in the specified period, but denominator populations varied depending on the condition being analysed. We used an interrupted time-series analysis to formally quantify changes in conditions after the introduction of population-wide restrictions (defined as March 29, 2020) compared with the period before their introduction (defined as Jan 1, 2017 to March 7, 2020), with data excluded for an adjustment-to-restrictions period (March 8–28).
Findings
The overall population included 9 863 903 individuals on Jan 1, 2017, and increased to 10 226 939 by Jan 1, 2020. Primary care contacts for almost all conditions dropped considerably after the introduction of population-wide restrictions. The largest reductions were observed for contacts for diabetic emergencies (odds ratio 0·35 [95% CI 0·25–0·50]), depression (0·53 [0·52–0·53]), and self-harm (0·56 [0·54–0·58]). In the interrupted time-series analysis, with the exception of acute alcohol-related events (0·98 [0·89–1·10]), there was evidence of a reduction in contacts for all conditions (anxiety 0·67 [0·66–0·67], eating disorders 0·62 [0·59–0·66], obsessive-compulsive disorder [0·69 [0·64–0·74]], self-harm 0·56 [0·54–0·58], severe mental illness 0·80 [0·78–0·83], stroke 0·59 [0·56–0·62], transient ischaemic attack 0·63 [0·58–0·67], heart failure 0·62 [0·60–0·64], myocardial infarction 0·72 [0·68–0·77], unstable angina 0·72 [0·60–0·87], venous thromboembolism 0·94 [0·90–0·99], and asthma exacerbation 0·88 [0·86–0·90]). By July, 2020, except for unstable angina and acute alcohol-related events, contacts for all conditions had not recovered to pre-lockdown levels.
Interpretation
There were substantial reductions in primary care contacts for acute physical and mental conditions following the introduction of restrictions, with limited recovery by July, 2020. Further research is needed to ascertain whether these reductions reflect changes in disease frequency or missed opportunities for care. Maintaining health-care access should be a key priority in future public health planning, including further restrictions. The conditions we studied are sufficiently severe that any unmet need will have substantial ramifications for the people with the conditions as well as health-care provision.
Funding
Wellcome Trust Senior Fellowship, Health Data Research UK.
Results
Table 2General denominator population defined in the first week of each year from 2017 to 2020

Figure 1Proportions of each study population with contacts for each condition in 2017–19 and 2020
Percentage of eligible population with contacts for each health condition studied in 2020 compared with the historical (2017–19) average for that week. Shaded regions show the difference between the 2020 data and the historical average. Vertical dashed lines indicate the introduction of lockdown restrictions in the UK on March 23, 2020. Tick marks on the x-axis represent the first day of the specified month. COPD=chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

Figure 2Percentage of each denominator population with general practitioner contacts for the study conditions throughout 2020, by age group

Figure 3Interrupted time-series analysis of changes in general practitioner contacts before and after the introduction of UK-wide restrictions
Table 3Estimated reduction in number of primary care contacts
Discussion
Primary care contacts for key physical and mental health conditions dropped considerably after the introduction of population-wide restriction measures in March, 2020. By July, 2020, with the exception of unstable angina and acute alcohol-related contacts, primary care contacts for all conditions studied remained below pre-lockdown levels. We estimated that by July, 2020, per million people in the general population, there were very small (<10) drops in the cumulative number of contacts for myocardial infarction, unstable angina, and venous thromboembolism. However, we estimated large drops for anxiety, depression, and COPD contacts.
- Williams R
- Jenkins DA
- Ashcroft DM
- et al.
In contrast to the Salford study, our sample was nationally representative and focused on contacts for specific disease categories that we would expect to present to health-care providers. Our large sample size allowed us to investigate detailed diagnoses (for example, different types of cardiovascular disease and mental health conditions).
,
Appointments in general practice.
A study of 51 GP practices already offering remote consultations before the pandemic indicated a dip in overall consultations at the time of lockdown but, unlike our results for specific acute conditions, their post-lockdown overall consultation decrease was less extreme than that during the Christmas period of 2019.
- Clarke G
- Pariza P
- Wolters A
In England, there was a 30% decrease in GP consultations from the beginning to the end of March, 2020,
Appointments in general practice.
with an increase in calls to NHS 111, the non-urgent telephone helpline. However, over 50% (1 573 835 of 2 962 751) of these calls went unanswered.
- Shrivastav M
- Gibson Jr, W
- Shrivastav R
- et al.
,
- Apicella M
- Campopiano MC
- Mantuano M
- Mazoni L
- Coppelli A
- Del Prato S
Furthermore, there is evidence that other emergency situations impair control of diabetes.
- Hartmann-Boyce J
- Morris E
- Goyder C
- et al.
,
- Ng J
- Atkin SL
- Rigby AS
- Walton C
- Kilpatrick ES
,
- Fonseca VA
- Smith H
- Kuhadiya N
- et al.
Consequently, we would expect an increase, rather than decrease, in diabetic emergency contacts.
- Williams R
- Jenkins DA
- Ashcroft DM
- et al.
,
- Fersia O
- Bryant S
- Nicholson R
- et al.
Taken alongside findings of similar reductions in emergency department presentations and hospital admissions for cardiovascular outcomes in the UK, our findings highlight an area of major concern,
- Mafham MM
- Spata E
- Goldacre R
- et al.
,
- Ball S
- Banerjee A
- Berry C
- et al.
particularly as evidence from France indicates increased out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.
- Marijon E
- Karam N
- Jost D
- et al.
Severe COVID-19 affects the cardiovascular system;
- Roberts CM
- Levi M
- McKee M
- Schilling R
- Lim WS
- Grocott MPW
therefore, increased primary and secondary care presentations for cardiovascular disease are expected.
- Clerkin KJ
- Fried JA
- Raikhelkar J
- et al.
Indeed, it is possible that the more rapid recovery in unstable angina contacts (compared with other conditions included in our study) might reflect COVID-19-related cardiovascular disease. However, the number of unstable angina events recorded were small, so we are unable to draw any meaningful conclusions from these results.
- Schiavone M
- Gobbi C
- Biondi-Zoccai G
- et al.
- Berghaus TM
- Karschnia P
- Haberl S
- Schwaiblmair M
COPD is associated with more severe COVID-19,
- Alqahtani JS
- Oyelade T
- Aldhahir AM
- et al.
and individuals with COPD in the UK were recommended to avoid contact with others until September, 2020.
COVID-19: guidance on shielding and protecting people defined on medical grounds as extremely vulnerable.
,
- Kenyon CC
- Hill DA
- Henrickson SE
- Bryant-Stephens TC
- Zorc JJ
There is no compelling evidence that individuals with asthma are at greater risk of severe COVID-19 outcomes, although there was uncertainty at the onset of the pandemic.
- Williamson EJ
- Walker AJ
- Bhaskaran K
- et al.
,
- Antonicelli L
- Tontini C
- Manzotti G
- et al.
,
- Carli G
- Cecchi L
- Stebbing J
- Parronchi P
- Farsi A
Viruses commonly trigger asthma exacerbations, so we might have expected to see more asthma contacts. Anecdotally, GPs reported increased prescription of asthma therapies around the lockdown period,
Salbutamol (0301011R0).
which could explain initial increased asthma contacts. Similar increases in COPD exacerbation contacts were not seen around the introduction of restrictions, despite our definition including prescriptions for oral corticosteroids. One explanation might be that, as COPD is a progressive respiratory condition, individuals with COPD might have repeat prescriptions, reducing the need (compared with people with asthma) to stockpile drugs in a crisis.
- Daly M
- Sutin AR
- Robinson E
,
- Jia R
- Ayling K
- Chalder T
- et al.
,
Coronavirus and depression in adults, Great Britain.
,
- Qiu J
- Shen B
- Zhao M
- Wang Z
- Xie B
- Xu Y
,
- Iob E
- Steptoe A
- Fancourt D
and exacerbations of existing obsessive-compulsive disorder, severe mental illness, and eating disorders have also been reported.
- Benatti B
- Albert U
- Maina G
- et al.
,
- Fernández-Aranda F
- Casas M
- Claes L
- et al.
,
- Muruganandam P
- Neelamegam S
- Menon V
- Alexander J
- Chaturvedi SK
However, we saw a sustained reduction in primary care contacts for anxiety, depression, and other mental health conditions consistent with other reports;
- Williams R
- Jenkins DA
- Ashcroft DM
- et al.
this finding is concerning because the majority of common mental disorders are managed in primary care. Similarly, the observed reduction in health-care contacts for people with severe mental illness is concerning because these individuals are likely to be at greater risk of poor outcomes from COVID-19 because of the high prevalence of risk factors for adverse outcomes in this group (eg, cardiovascular disease and deprivation).
- Williamson EJ
- Walker AJ
- Bhaskaran K
- et al.
,
- Gierisch JM
- Nieuwsma JA
- Bradford DW
- et al.
,
- Foguet-Boreu Q
- Fernandez San Martin MI
- Flores Mateo G
- et al.
Alcohol consumption during the COVID-19 lockdown: summary of emerging evidence from the UK.
We saw primary care contacts for acute alcohol-related events increase before and after restrictions, which is troubling given the reduction in contacts for other conditions studied; however, we urge caution in drawing robust conclusions as numbers were small.
This study involved a rapid assessment of changes in primary care contacts following the introduction of UK population-wide restrictions up to July, 2020, in a large sample representative of the UK population. Historical data allowed us to compare observed patterns in 2020 with trends in the previous 3 years. We estimated relative and absolute changes in contact patterns, with a focus on easy to interpret measures.
Our study describes and quantifies the reduction in primary care contacts across a wide range of health conditions likely to be affected by COVID-19 to generate hypotheses. However, further research is needed to understand the specific drivers behind these changes (eg, individuals could have limited their in-person contact through fear of SARS-CoV-2 infection, or might have had difficulty accessing primary care services because of unavailability of appointments or lack of available technology or technological literacy for virtual consultations). It is important that we understand what happened to individuals who did not consult their GP—specifically, whether they were treated in secondary care or self-managed, and to what extent our findings can be explained by genuine changes in disease frequency.
Coronavirus (COVID-19) in the UK: healthcare in United Kingdom.
which would not account for the sudden and large decline in primary care contacts that we saw across most conditions studied.
Another potential explanation for our findings could be related to changes in how primary care contacts were documented following a rapid shift to remote consultations. However, we feel that the conditions we studied are sufficiently severe that it is unlikely that diagnoses would not have been recorded. To avoid problems arising from the timing of behavioural change associated with restrictions, our interrupted time-series analysis excluded a predefined intervention period when individuals’ behaviours were changing dynamically. We took a conservative approach and defined our intervention period between March 8 and March 28, 2020, assuming that some people would have modified their behaviour before the introduction of restrictions. Sensitivity analyses varying the start date showed consistent findings with those of the main analysis.
- Williams R
- Jenkins DA
- Ashcroft DM
- et al.
is beyond the scope of this Article, and any changes in health-seeking behaviour would not have reduced the need for care.
,
- Mafham MM
- Spata E
- Goldacre R
- et al.
,
- Mulholland RH
- Wood R
- Stagg HR
- et al.
,
- Maringe C
- Spicer J
- Morris M
- et al.
although one explanation could be genuine changes in disease frequency (which is unlikely, given consistent results across disease categories), it is more likely that our findings reflect missed opportunities for care. There are plausible mechanisms that might explain real reductions in frequency for some of our outcomes, such as better glycaemic control in diabetes because of more regular routines when staying home; less respiratory disease because of lower exposure to air pollution during lockdown,
and reduced community-acquired respiratory infections because of shielding guidelines;
COVID-19: guidance on shielding and protecting people defined on medical grounds as extremely vulnerable.
and reduced alcohol consumption due to pub closures and reduced social contact. Conversely, there are plausible mechanisms that could explain genuine increased frequency of these conditions (eg, distress related to the pandemic affecting mental health and alcohol consumption, reduced exercise affecting cardiovascular health, changes in diet influencing glycaemic control). Additionally, for some of our outcomes, such as mental health conditions, some evidence indicates increased frequency.
- Daly M
- Sutin AR
- Robinson E
,
- Jia R
- Ayling K
- Chalder T
- et al.
,
Coronavirus and depression in adults, Great Britain.
,
- Qiu J
- Shen B
- Zhao M
- Wang Z
- Xie B
- Xu Y
,
- Benatti B
- Albert U
- Maina G
- et al.
,
- Fernández-Aranda F
- Casas M
- Claes L
- et al.
,
- Muruganandam P
- Neelamegam S
- Menon V
- Alexander J
- Chaturvedi SK
Increases in non-COVID-19-related excess mortality also make it more likely that our observed reduction in primary care contacts was due to behavioural changes rather than reduced disease frequency.
- Jia R
- Ayling K
- Chalder T
- et al.
,
,
- Kim JU
- Majid A
- Judge R
- et al.
,
- McAuley HJC
- Hadley K
- Elneima O
- et al.
,
Furthermore, emerging evidence of the systemic complications of SARS-CoV-2 infection (particularly cardiovascular disease and diabetes)
,
- Nishiga M
- Wang DW
- Han Y
- Lewis DB
- Wu JC
,
- Varatharaj A
- Thomas N
- Ellul MA
- et al.
indicates that we might have expected more need for care for these conditions as a direct result of the pandemic.
The current pandemic has generated a wealth of experience with alternative ways to access care remotely.
- Greenhalgh T
- Wherton J
- Shaw S
- Morrison C
These lessons must be systematised and implemented.
In summary, this study showed substantial reductions in primary care contacts for various acute physical and mental health conditions. Our findings are likely to represent a considerable burden of unmet need, which might lead to substantial increases in subsequent mortality and morbidity.
All study authors were involved in the development of the study, contributed to the development of the code lists that defined the variables used in the study, and contributed to and approved the final manuscript. RM, JT, ADH, HC, PB, and AYSW were responsible for data management. RM, JT, ADH, and ARM were responsible for statistical analyses. KEM, RM, JT, ADH, and ARM wrote the first draft of the Article. All authors had access to all the data in the study, and all authors had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication. HC, JT and RM accessed and verified the data.
RM reports personal fees from Amgen outside of the submitted work. CW-G reports grants from the Wellcome Trust during the conduct of the study. LS reports grants from United Kingdom Research and Innovation during the conduct of the study; grants from Wellcome, the UK Medical Research Council (MRC), the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR), GlaxoSmithKline, the British Heart Foundation, Diabetes UK, and the Newton Fund outside of the submitted work; and is a non-executive director of the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency. AG works for AstraZeneca outside of the submitted work. JKQ reports grants and personal fees from AstraZeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, GlaxoSmithKline, Bayer, and Chiesi; grants from The Health Foundation and the MRC; and study funding from Asthma UK outside of the submitted work. MM is a member of Independent SAGE. SML reports grants from the Wellcome Trust, NIHR, MRC, and Health Data Research UK during the conduct of the study. All other authors declare no competing interests.
